Hey, Joss likes boys too!…..wait, no, that came out wrong
Friday, May 7th, 2010Very amusing video up above. For one it reveals just how often we’re expected to support the careers of talentless husks in today’s culture, but talented creators often have to fight and claw their way to achieve a decent measure of success.
Joss Whedon is an example of this. He is not the Messiah, but he is a decent enough writer. What’s more he actually (prepare to roll your eyes at me) cares about the issues he raises in his stories.
In addition, as the video points out, he has created some notable female leads. Man ten years go by with no one but Sarah Connor, or Ellen Ripley and then out of the blue we’re knee-deep in Buffys, Willows, Faiths, Inaras, Kaylees, Echos and Sierras.
Now that’s all well and good as far as having a collection of poster-girls for that feminist edition of Loaded that you’ll never see….but feminism isn’t just about women. It’s about men too. I’ve always thought the real goal of feminism is not only to empower women, but to change the way men think about their roles also.
In that line of thinking, Joss has also introduced us to a number of male characters that were a refreshing change from the morbid machismo of the cartoonish action hero (see here for example). The chicks kicked ass, despite being dainty size zeros, but the male leads had a tendency to be goofballs, or wry adventurers instead of emotionless Austrian hardmen.
Hardly a copernican revolution in terms of what a male action hero can be, but lets call it a sly inversion anyway. Remember when we first met John McClane? Bruce Willis lent a certain degree of wit to that performance as a beat cop trapped on the roof of Nakatomi Plaza taking out well-armed terrorists. Then the sequelitis killed off whatever trace of that there was, so that by Die Hard 4.0 (ugh!) he was jumping on top of jets and self-censoring bad language with gun shots. Anyway my point is, Joss took an aspect of that action hero as comic persona and refined it so that John McClane turned into ….Xander Harris of all people! The muscleman learned to feel emotion, act like an idiot and yes, fuck up every now and then. It’s not too much of a stretch, there’s even a Buffy the Vampire Slayer parody of Die Hard, titled School Hard of course. Xander is that everyman hero that McClane could not be allowed to remain. He survives desperate situations by a combination of luck and plucky determination. Plus he makes you laugh.
Remember ‘bitca’?
Here’s a few other male characters that Joss created, with a little twist on the familiar format.

Rupert Giles
Buffy fangirls have their Spike and their Angel shipper fantasies, but to my mind it was the librarian-cum-Watcher Giles who was always the most interesting character. Introduced in the first season as an obvious paternalistic figure to the rebellious Buffy Summers, a child of divorce looking for direction and guidance in her bizarre life of dating boys and vampire kung fu, he seemed so….well British for one. Anthony Stewart Head claims to have based his performance on Alan Rickman and Hugh Grant and there’s a certain colonial condescension there that fits in with the male authority figure he appears to represent.
Then Buffy started to challenge his authority and guess what? He backed down. When he did disagree with her it was often as an equal. This had a double effect – it led into the empowering of Buffy as a young woman, but also freed up Giles to be a more amusing, offhand character, noticeably more relaxed than the subsequent Watchers that appeared on the show. It is made clear that his relationship with the Slayer is considered shocking, despite their successes as a team. The Watcher order is greatly disturbed that Giles has abandoned the controlling behaviour used to bend the supernaturally empowered Slayers, who are always young women, to their will. Furthermore Rupert, or ‘Ripper’, as he is nicknamed by former associates, is discovered to have something of a past. He was the Sid Vicious of the magic scene it would appear, dabbling in the dark arts for thrills and excitement. So when we meet the buttoned down librarian in the first season of Buffy, we are actually seeing someone who has spent a lifetime repressing his wilder instincts.
It’s a fascinating evolution of a character.

Malcolm Reynolds
When Joss cast Nathan Fillion as Mal, former rebel fighter and smuggler by trade, captain of the star-freighter Serenity, he really struck gold. Firefly fans are notorious for their devotion to the prematurely cancelled show and I would argue that that is due in no small part to Fillion’s performance as the rakish Mal.
Here’s the high concept. He’s Han Solo, but better written and morally complex. He would always shoot Greedo first and then afterwards, quip about it.
What’s more, buried beneath the bluster and career criminal pragmatism, he also cares about desperate causes, much like Joss. There’s a sense that having been on the wrong side of a civil war has broken him badly and it is not until his encounter with the Tam siblings, fugitives from the law and in need of shelter, that he rediscovers a cause worth fighting for, or indeed a purpose to life beyond putting food on the table for his crew.
Firefly and Buffy share the theme of choosing your own family and in many ways Mal’s character arc over the meagre half season that was broadcast, as well as the spin-off movie Serenity, describes his acceptace of the role of father to this motley band of criminals and outcasts.
Possibly my favourite scene that illustrates Mal’s nature is this moment from the conclusion of the episode Shindig. Having just defeated the conceited fop Atherton in a fencing match, Reynolds stands over his rival’s prone body:
- Sir Warrick: You have to finish it, lad. [Mal doesn't move] You have to finish it. For a man to lay beaten, yet breathing? It makes him a coward.
- Inara: It’s humiliation.
- Mal: It would be humiliating, having to lie there while the better man refuses to spill your blood. Mercy is the mark of a great man.
- [He lightly stabs Atherton.]
- Mal: Guess I’m just a good man.
- [He repeats the poking.]
- Mal: Well, I’m all right.

Victor
Ah Victor, Victor, Victor, Victor. The thinking woman’s crumpet this one. See here Joss was covering his bases quite nicely. Try explaining the concept behind Dollhouse to the average person and they’ll probably (and with just cause) react with horror. Isn’t this a show about institutionalised rape and human trafficking?
Well yes. Yes it is. That is the point Joss is making, that there are those in society who exploit and use the poor and defenceless without scruples. That frequently this will be justified as legitimate ‘business’, or a mere commercial exchange. After all, isn’t the customer always right? When the vendor in question is a prostitute, even a high-class one, their rights are not really all that important.
Which is what the Dollhouse is, an exclusive and very sophisticated brothel for the captains of industry. It hires out ‘Dolls’, men and women whose memories of their former lives have been erased and can quite easily be programmed to be whomever you want them to be. Now if this were anyone else but Joss, I imagine that previous sentence would end ‘….with sexy results’.
But this is Joss and frankly, he seems angry. Victor is a product of that anger. At times the most innocent of the Dolls, in his wiped state he is childlike and troubled by the pain exhibited by others. When on assignment, all traces of doubt and unworldliness disappear and we are treated to a series of fantastic performances by actor Enver Gjokaj. In one episode he essays an David Niven-esque British lover to Olivia Williams’ Adelle DeWitt. In another an Italian art agent. He also takes on the role of a blank-faced intelligence agent, but then blink and he’ll become desperate low-level Russian mobster. It’s a showcase to the talent of actor Gjokaj and Joss gives him every opportunity to display his range. In keeping with the theme of my post, Victor is a broad canvas of male behaviour, running the gamut from sheltered boy to amorous lover and then switch to shell-shocked veteran, or crazed genius.
Victor is in a sense the best example of Joss’ challenge to broadcast television. In keeping with his feminist principles, he demands that character come first, not product, themes that matter, not cliches.
The girls kick arse, but the guys are pretty awesome too.
I was going to add Doc Horrible, but frankly that’s a whole other post.

Once again we were treated to the Doctor’s sadness at being the last of the Timelords, his feelings of responsibility for their deaths and the destruction of Gallifrey. Even a psychopath like the Master is welcome company to him, as he’s desperately lonely. I really liked that touch and it excuses any of RTD’s usual deus ex machina plotting. Golum Doctor looked a bit odd though.